Saturday, October 31, 2026

One less textbook

If your kid's college is assigning Emmanuel Saez: pull him out. Honest economists (who exist) have been trying to refute Saez and his cowriter Piketty for almost a quarter-century but got stonewalled. AI is denting this wall.

Gabriel Zucman seems to be aware of the grift to which he's attached himself, since he is hurriedly blocking his comments.

It's the same phenomenon noted with Loonybins Johnson: mistakes happen, and sometimes they're neutral or even contrary to the thesis; but overall the mistakes trend toward the same direction. This is strong evidence of Tendenz.

When it happens in the medical sciences, we call in an auditor for suspected fraud. When some obvious ideologue (like Johnson) does this, we laugh him out of the classroom. But in economics? we just pat the scholars on the head, those lovable scamps. Shenanigans!

No comments:

Post a Comment