Saturday, November 21, 2026

The backup safety generator

If our cities can't get small nuclear reactors, we'll need to improve our large ones. ToughSF has reached through his time-machine and brought Khalil Moshkbar-Bakhshayesh from next month.

The idea here is that nuclear reactions emit electromagnetic-radiation - light - and we're using only the infrared and microwave of that, to boil fluids presumed water (or supercritical CO2, doesn't-matter). The sheer power of a large reactor will be emitting a good deal of this energy into the X-ray spectra which atomic physicists enumerate γ. Beyond what a vantablack paint-job can catch, is wasted. Dangerously wasted, for bystanders...

Some of that radiation can be captured - and that capture is going to be close to home. Per the abstract Photon Intermediate Direct Energy Conversion (PIDEC) addresses this by converting gamma radiation into usable power. In the Discussion: During operation, this amounts to nearly 90 MWth for a 3000 MWth plant, while postshutdown values average over 2 MWth during a typical outage. Paper implies "th" for "thermal" i.e. electromagnetic.

Large plants, you see, waste more light. That capture should suffice to run... the plant itself. By thermodynamics it's all going to be wasted eventually anyway, but it should be put to work as far as possible in the meantime. Note that as radiation, even if we've had a horrendous shutdown of the fluid-boiling, χMB should still be able to catch the rays themselves.

This paper is so hot off the press it hath bent time itself, so - take it as you will. Where χMB be wrong on detail, those details should be corrected.

The efficient booster

Last summer I looked into Reusable Launch Vehicle C5. This is a 2025-proposed hydrogen-burn booster for pushing 70 tonnes ("mt") into space. This nets us DreamChaser short-flights for return to Earth, or a chassis to be tugged into higher orbit for shuttling around elsewhere. Its sale-point was "efficiency". Do we care about efficiency?

The Germans cared in 2025, back when 70mt was as good as anything else. In 2026 Musk doesn't care... anymore, because his roggets are now mighty enough that tonnes-to-orbit exceed 70mt and are set to smoke it. Musk can tell the Germans with all honesty that nobody's getting delta-V savings in orbit until someone, first, puts cheap delta-V stations up there.

Musk's real reason is that natural gas is cheap where he's launching, presently the American Gulf. (He might have to consider Tamaulipas should the incoming Tejana government keep mouthing off, down where it's still the Mexican Gulf - but, they have methane too.) This is best for geostationary and ecliptic orbits. European capitalists, who still exist, prefer the polar orbits which include always-daylight, free-energy pathways. Those launches take off from cold rocky islands which may or may not have cheap hydrocarbons.

But but they have hydrogen from the ocean. Uh. The ocean is salty. But but but snow and fog? - direct "green hydrogen" demands energy even from pure H2O. Cheapest is still dirty hydrogen from methane; maybe from the methane hydrates of the northern undersea, doesn't matter. Still not as cheap as from the Gulf. But perhaps cheap-enough if they don't need as much.

The behemoth that is Starship is in position as the great space Exxon, delivering propellant and tethers mostly to equatorial range. Which can sell next-stage services to whatever other rockets send up, which can absolutely include the RLV C5.

Friday, November 20, 2026

V4

Starship lately returned from orbit in a feat we've not seen since the Shuttle. And it did so on a Superheavy booster designed to be reusable, which NASA and Reagan's Senate never allowed for the Shuttle.

That shameless toff Richard Bowles has well-earned his place in Stephen Pile's next "art of being wrong" chapter. There's so much that could be ranted against Bowles and against Ariane's vision in general (let the children dream, so we can exploit their support) but our own dream is not to write that sort of blog anymore. At least the Germans are trying; their 70mt can be handled in a separate poast.

Of more interest is whither SpaceX goeth hence. Retrieving the overall frame from atmospheric plasma has been a Solved Problem for the setup's present mass and power; Musk said that when his earlier 'ship went sploosh and needed floating back. A less-Solved problem might be the damage from solids. Not all of it was from normal reëntry: 'ship scraped the chopstick, like in Galaxy Quest. And is quick refurbishment and relaunch compatible with the months and months the Shuttle demanded?

'Ship reuse might not even be the focus - even yet. A new version cometh. Last Monday - h/t Zim, and these guys I guess - I checked a few youtubes, which align with Musk's recent pronouncements. You know how the present setup is to get 100-115 metric (mt) into orbit? V4 is for 200. 52.1m 'ship height? - make that 61m. Thus far, the promise of October 2025 - which I admit I didn't take seriously, but now we must. The Raptor 4 is being designed to make that possible, pending the reliability improvements of r3.2.

That 'ship volume means 'ship chassis and tiling, which means more engines: they want six for vacuum in addition to the three for atmo. 'Ship propellant must go from 1600mt to 2300mt. The booster will have to be taller too; to push present 8240 tonnes of force, to 10000 tf. I take it that means 98 MN; so given 33 Raptors, the r4 must deliver 3 MN apiece. To remind, r4 is in-progress.

As an aside, an earlier poast here had pondered the use of refueling in orbit if only 100mt of propellant could get up there at one time. It looks (much) more feasible at 200 at a time. For tetherbros that's 200mt of Dyneema cable at a time.

Tethers, I think, will be where satellites compete if they don't reuse the 'ship. We'll note that SpaceX doesn't care for fuel efficiency; for those hoping to compete on fuel cost alone, refer above to the Germans. Say the Germans leave their client's 70mt in space. That cargo won't need the three non-vac engines (meant for landing) nor, if not Venus-/Uranus-bound, the heat shield. They can stick with space-mucking. If they don't have Raptor engines, tethers tug the 70mt to the higher orbits where they can light the H10 or some skiffy engine instead.

Thursday, November 19, 2026

Dynamic topography

Some Aussies, Santosh Dhungana and Nicolas Flament, are looking at the rise and fall of our pre-Cryogenic continents. Here in old Laurentia, we have an Unconformity over the "boring billion" between Vishnu and Cordillerian, the latter being our local Vendi'Carian.

And they've pegged this topographic "dynamism": relatively stable between 900 Ma and 800 Ma, increased rapidly between 800 Ma and 720 Ma, followed by a gradual increase between 720 Ma and 600 Ma, and a rapid decrease between 600 Ma and 420 Ma. 825-765 "Ma", or Mya as I call it, spans the Rodinia breakup into (large!) islands like Laurentia. 717 Mya ushered the Sturtian snowball.

This is like old Zealandia, now sunken. Usually continents don't sink, they move; via plate-tectonics. Dhungana-Flament are saying Earth's continents were more Zealander during the Boring era (or, some may say... Atlantean). Magma was more forceful and our crust, weaker.

This would explain how a craton, which might even have been a (shallow) shelf, upwelled after its divorce from Rodinia.

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Why Joshua 6 may be earlier

I noted earlier how Ernst Knauf assessed the construction of our book "Joshua". He thought that our Joshua 6 was inherited from prior lore; much like parts of Judges (say, Samson... and his heir Samuel). Some might ask how Knauf came to that assumption.

To that, here is Emmanuel Tov on possible theological motives in translating the Bible into Greek. Of course Isaiah has suffered a lot of this, and Tov could have added certain Psalms. We tend to associate 1 Samuel with Masoretic mungling, but 1 Reigns 2:2 / Hanna's Ode has turned her "rock (צור)" into δίκαιος. The LXX proper, although Tov didn't say specifically, had a bunch of little tweaks before even making it to the translator; Tov sees a (further) switch from pre-Samaritan Gabur Malhama over to something like "*Sabur (συντρίβων) Malhama". Tov cites Exodus 24:10 (the place where the god of Israel stood) as a possible translator's emendation although I'd not be surprised to find it in some ancient pesher or variant Hebrew scroll.

Anyhoo, Joshua 6 was one of the parts where the Greek translator really let loose with some Orthodox Corruption. The law in Numbers 10, which is also in LXX, restricts the trumpet to the priests. In MT Joshua, the hero uses it against Jericho - famously. One assumes that the king also got to use it in his own time. So this law is likely a Second Temple restriction if not Hasmonaean. That left the offhand note in Jericho, hanging. The Greek translation, which might even be LXX, locks down the trumpets.

This discomfort upon the translators and exegetes supports Knauf's instinct that in MT Joshua 6, we really are looking at a holdover from a less pious time.

The space tarp

Sciencedaily has floated UPenn's space tarp. It's made of the mylar/aluminum rags given to marathon runners. For non-trademark purpose, we call it biaxially oriented polyethylene terephthalate: BoPET.

The main use-case is for wrapping structures on the Lunar surface. Blah blah permanent structures should be buried under regolith, or built in those 17°C caves etc etc. But they're going to need Quonset huts on the surface in the meantime, wherever prospectors are afoot, including prospecting for those caves. Also, the tunnels to connect those huts.

I wonder if BoPET needs papering over the Kevlar (trademark, again) spaceline to TLL1, also. They don't get "night" exactly but they do get ST (seen on Terra as "lunar") and SL ("solar") eclipses. Like, all of them.

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

The nazir in 1 Samuel

Anneli Aejmelaeus looks at the first volume of Samuel.

We have several texts for 1 Samuel in Greek - including the α. Aejmelaeus did not find Old Latin to back α, only Lucianic (as "1 Reigns") or Vulgatic. Our modern author did, however, have 4QSama/4Q51 and Ben Sira 46 in Hebrew, and Josephus in Greek pulling directly from Hebrew. That Hebrew was no proto-MT elsewhere and Aejmelaeus finds likewise here.

As a side-product, the α translator proves ... I'm not going to say inept, but let's say a Hebrew-2L as can be seen here. The Hebrew Torahs hurt his head. So when he translated from his Samuel text, he did not refer to a Torah glossary. Instead he used the Greek Septuagint exclusively. The LXX had already translated "nazir" to "prophet", and this is how Ben Sira's translator and Josephus translate it, both of them being excellent Hebrew scholars. In 1 Sam 1:11, Hanna is devoting the child as a nazir (or so Cross reconstructed for 4QSama). The α translator might or might not have deemed "prophet"; Aejmelaeus argues that α did not know to use the term, because he'd spurned the Hebrew Torah. Further, the book of Judges was not available as such in Greek, missing in particular the Samson story. Aejmelaeus believes Samson-as-nazir available to 1 Samuel 1-8's Hebrew author; but again, α was no scholar of Hebrew text. So α punts: δοτὸς, "pledge".

Now we get to the Masoretes. Aejmelaeus argues that in the days before Mishnah, halakha was pulled from the Prophets. Samuel was a prophet, and David was his Anointed; their deeds were had through 1 Samuel. Aejmelaeus observes that Mark's Gospel has Jesus - his Davidic messiah - argue halakha through 1 Samuel 21. As Mishnah evolved, it argued that Hanna was wrong to devote Samuel as a nazir; only a man should do that. The Masoretes - Aejmelaeus argues - took the shortcut of rewriting Hanna. Hanna only commends Samuel; their community commits him.

One possibility is that the MT is rejecting the feminism of the Liber Antiquitatum Biblicarum here. Except that the LAB seems dependent on MT 1 Sam 1:6-7,16 where a rival mocks Hanna, absent from α.

I wonder if the MT's rejection be, more-narrowly, of Elizabeth devoting Joh[ana]n to the nazirate. I'm not discussing Mary and Jesus, whose protevangel is fraught; mind, to the extent I'm talking to Christians (or to Mandaeans or to Muslims), I don't need to discuss them, because all sing in unison John came first. Note that so does Josephus. Is the MT revision, evidence of an antiJohannine faction?

Monday, November 16, 2026

Revisiting the boron rocket

Whilst traipsing through this blog (again) I ran across the boron-hydrogen process. This fusion drive is aneutronic beyond Princeton's DFD, and with boron instead of near-unobtainial Helium-3. If we can get it started...

Boron's five electrons force a Bremsstrahlung effect. This imposes a constraint for fusion power-generation ... on Earth; but we're building a rocket, which is ejecting that heat. The rocketeer can consider the helium "ash" buildup, likewise: for us, it's hot propellant. The Marylanders have assured us that they could harness this.

Sparking these atoms to fuse in the first place has been assumed 130 keV optimistically, and "realistically" 400. Even before 2023, Matheson and Hooper over at the Utah Valley Rifle Range had fired some shots (pdf) at the boron process, without considering Bremsstrahlung.

Lately Oleg Agamalov is looking at 850 keV for efficiency; which he would rather round 0.85 MeV. This is a function of injector voltage. For that, we defer to Eos Atomics, assuming they stay the course for a change.

Or maybe someone'll use a muon. I'm calling that to run 875 keV for a rocket, or to spin up (heh) a freakin' exotic: that spark will need supply from an outside station.

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Deutero-Thessalonians

Everyone agrees that Paul wrote a letter to the Christians at Thessalonica - among those in favour, the author of the New Testament's second letter thereto. This blog has been assuming that there was no real second letter. This derives from Bart Ehrman and lately Richard Carrier. Lately it occurs to me that the NT doesn't contain all of the Pauline corpus, forged or not. "Hebrews", "3 Corinthians", "Laodiceans" are famous; "2 Colossians" perhaps less-so. But also the Corinthians got a "lachrymose letter" after the first one; scholars still argue over that one's content, but all agree it was before or during canon 2 Cor.

So let us take our Second Thessalonians seriously - as Third Thessalonians.

As "3 Thessalonians", I for now set aside its authorship. I aim for what this missive was trying to refute, which was intimately involved with 1 Thess. "3 Thess", whether or not an authorial conceit, presented the Thessalonica Christendom as the recent recipients of a Pauline correspondence. Some say they can extract the Lachrymose content from what 2 Corinthians alludes. This poast will extract Deutero-Thessalonians from the allusions in what I'm (for now) calling "3 Thess".

What is refuted in "3 Thess" is not 1 Thess. "3 Thess" takes pains to parallel 1 Thess, as a common ground with the audience... and with Deutero-Thessalonians.

Deutero-Thessalonians stood in between. Its author was a Pauline, like the author of "Hebrews" and indeed like that of "1 Clement". Our man adhered closer than they to Paul's belief that the End was nigh. To repeat, 1 Thess was a shared text; although yet without the antiJewish interpolation, given that "3 Thess" won't address that pericope either. Deutero-Thessalonians also paralleled Philippians 4:5 that the Lord be at hand. Or even Romans 13:11-12.

Now: I doubt "3 Thess" would have attacked Philippians and I don't think anyone is claiming it had a problem with Romans, either. Deutero-Thessalonians had to stand out from these other works. One way it could so have done, would be to make claims about specific events of the Last Day. This is exactly what "3 Thess" will do: for that day will not come unless the rebellion comes first and the lawless one is revealed, the one destined for destruction.

Deutero-Thessalonians may have named an evil leader, termed "godless" and/or "christless". He would have gone to "destruction" as to herald the Day which Paul had promised. The laws of Rome no longer mattered any more than did the laws of the Jews. This all would be in parallel with the Revelation and 1 John, on "antichrists" - but stronger. One can ponder several Roman emperors who might fit this bill; over AD 68-9 Rome speedran four of them, as gamers might put it.

In Paul's own time, Tiberius had presided over the death of Jesus (and others), and Gaius Caligula was... Gaius Caligula. Claudius had enemies too.

The spiciest take of all might be that Paul authentically wrote Deutero-Thessalonians as his last testament on the coming apocalypse, from his prison in Spain. When he was executed and the apocalypse did not happen, his successors had to scribble out 3 Thess - now, "2 Thessalonians" - to stem the riot. The implication is that the rebels might be, themselves, breaking the restraint which is placed upon the antichrist. The eschaton is not to be immanentised.

Saturday, November 14, 2026

Cheaper monoxide

Two decades ago Robert Zubrin pointed us to carbon monoxide's potential on Mars.

One use was for making methanol, as an easier-transportable liquid: Brookhaven's method is still up (doi 10.1021/jacs.3c14605), and we also own plenty of syngas articles. One constraint for all hydrocarbons was to get the hydrogen from water rather than, as over Venus, from acid; but let's assume a gentler planet for now. Or simply a planetoid we're mining with robots as don't need the hydrogen.

Our universal precursor is to get the monoxide from the dioxide. Brookhaven in March 2024 had handwaved this as photochemical reduction. ToughSF might be providing the basis for that assessment, from 2021: A Microwave-Assisted Boudouard Reaction: A Highly Effective Reduction of the Greenhouse Gas CO2 to Useful CO Feedstock with Semi-Coke. A look through Google Scholar, turns up that it's an ongoing field of study. For instance here.

The temperature mooted in that last, from 2024, was 796 °C which is 1070 K. That is hotter than Venus' surface. But it should be workable with a small modular reactor, on any planet. Also recommended is a catalyst, Barium Carbonate in 2021 (for 750°). None of the catalysts look terribly exotic.

Friday, November 13, 2026

Another Syrian florilegium

Western scholarship has not compiled a critical-text of Ignatius' work in its Syriac form. It may be just as well, given how our best witnesses to this form of the text are not, in fact, copies of a coherent collexion. The epistle to the Romans was translated independently: one version as part of the saint's Vita, and others as parts of whatever other project(s) - like Timothy Aelurus' project Against the Dyophysites. And then there's the florilegium which lacks Romans entire.

That florilegium was already known to Lightfoot as S1. Other Syriac MSS in Lightfoot's day were 14577 / S2 (which includes the letter to Hero), 17134 / S3, and CUL MS Add. 2023 / S4.

Dan Batovici, with Giorgia Nicosia, has lately published another florilegium - DS 28A. This one quotes Romans from outside the Vita; marked as the seventh. This implies the existence of six earlier letters; of which, the fifth is what we call "Trallians" and what the other florilegium called "Titilians".

As to Pento/Titilia 6:1-2, these overlap. DS 28A is the fuller text against S1. These excerpts are not in any dedicated MSS so-far found, but they likely descend from the same source - and that source was not itself a florilegium. Batovici-Nicosia accept DS 28A that a Syrian recension of at least seven letters existed.

DS 28A is marked as "Syro-Orthodox" here. If I may clarify, its fathers include protoMaronite Jacob of Serugh and full Miaphysite Severus of Antioch. But we also get John Chrysostom and Theodoret of Cyrrhus; teacher and ally of Nestorius. Maybe that's why we're looking at Estrangela for the recent article's script. Maybe that's why Aelurus the Miaphysite ignored these excerpts, to do his own translation.

But we cannot assume the Syrian recension's identity with the "middle recension" of the Greek. It probably included the letter to Hero. This recension with Hero is what needs in any critical edition of the Syriac. By contrast the version of that to the Romans found in the Vita, and mutually independent ad-hocs like Aelurus', are to be excluded. I should further bypass DS 28A's Smyrnaeans 4.1b inasmuch as this quote is nested (under Theodoret). And I'd advise caution against DS 28A's little glosses except that Batovici-Nicosia are already aware of these.

I am not advising that Hero belongs in the critical edition of the Greek (in the way the Vita and Aelurus really would be useful, as independent checks on Greek Romans). Hero hasn't (yet) figured anywhere in the Syrian florilegia. Hero's content isn't obviously weird, but that may be the problem: it's an uninteresting pastiche, like "Laodiceans" or "3 Corinthians"... or "2 Colossians". Richard Carrier would add "1 Timothy".

Thursday, November 12, 2026

The Levites' prayer, II

Last I looked at Nehemiah 9, I gathered 2010s-decadal research into a summary. It turns out that Marshal Cunningham was also doing this in 2023, but competently. The consensus of the early 2020s, we both agree, is that the prayer depends upon the Torah we got, but - nonetheless - that it floated outside the canon. Until Nehemiah's editors made the call to include it.

When reading it, Cunningham noticed that it doesn't mention the exile. That may be a problem for any argument that Nehemiah composed this work; but is an equal problem for the argument that the Torah is, likewise, a post-exilic document.

Cunningham argues here for a social amnesia. He doesn't bring up Orwell; he doesn't have to. In the Levitic mind, as opposed to the Deuteronomic, Jeremiahvic, or Ezekielian: Judah was handed over to Babylon but only the sinners were exiled thither. The people of Judah-and-Levi have inherited a land that was always theirs. Very golah might still mean scouring.

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Revisiting sodium and lithium

Matt Ferrell updates us on the +1 ions, for cathodes. Here on this blog, I'd looked at sodium as an alternative to lithium. But since 2021ish we've found absolute mounds of lithium, with more to come, so the price has crashed.

We can however compete at the niches, like cell life. Sodium happens to compete with this and also works better at sharp swings of ambient temperature. This makes sodium work well near where solar power is viable, out in the deserts; which also happens to be near supplies of sodium in Wyoming (and Utah, I believe). Ferrell notes a company that is using passive cooling out there which is electricity that doesn't need for itself.

As to why sodium which is so much more common than lithium is struggling on raw price, elsewhere: Ferrell reminds us of the anode counterparty. This is "just" carbon... opposite lithium cathodes. Although graphite will do for lithium, the sodium cathodes must speak to better carbon. Ferrell notes coconut shells(!), or anthracite. I know we have lotsa coal but anthracite is a little harder to find.

As to why we want solar/battery driving electricity through the middle of apparent nowhere: the old Bonneville coast in Utah hosts several cities, of which SLC is comparable to Denver. Arizona and Nevada also have energy-hungry cities. They have mines out West, elsewhere. And if nothing else, as vehicles get electrified (sodium is tagged here as well, for those cross-country trips), they'll need electrical power top-ups.

Proposal

Today is the anniversary of Armistice. Americans honor their veterans, whilst Europeans respect the fallen. All may ponder the human cost of war. Except for Israel, whose war is ongoing. (To disclose: Ace has banned me - again - for the short version of this comment.)

Support for Israel is often termed support for "genocide". This post isn't going to assume that. A softer form is that it is support for "war", and/or "apartheid". This post will accept "apartheid" for the sake of argument, but will duck the morality thereof (inasmuch as Islam also prescribes apartheid, for Jews: dhimmat). This day is a day to look at war.

One may retort that it takes two to make a war, and that Israel's enemies aren't asking for ceasefires, so why pick on Israel, especially given the other wars Israel's enemies are fighting with nary a Jew in sight. Often amongst each other.

I have to ponder the thought that as long as Israel exists where it is, that war will not stop. The so-called "neo conservatives" have made their peace with that, so to speak. Meanwhile those of us whose income streams aren't that high are paying the price for it. Which is why the Republicans lost so hard. (And not by "fraud". And the $4.25 petrol signs where I live were not an op.)

Another reason the Republicans lost was that the Jewish vote the Republicans were chasing - the Scot Aronson vote - didn't come. I came, but I'm only 30% Jew (and only 30% of Jews joined me). Aronson and Woit got into their mutual insult-flinging, none of which budged Aronson on the topic of the Republicans as MAGA fascists or whatever. Back in the early 1990s, James Baker warned us as much.

It's not as if the Israeli religions are even (remotely) likely to be true. We've had thirty years of Robert Spencer and others trying to convince everyone that Islam is comparatively false and evil. (To disclose, again: I've done mine own research on Islam's falsity.) Look where we're at. So Zionists don't even have G-d on their side.

To sum up, we are prosecuting a war which won't end, absent a real genocide on one part or the other. The people on "our" side of that war are not on our side. Nobody's prayers are getting answered. Israelis represent, in south Syria, naught but a target; a bargaining-chip against all the world's other interests in the Near East. As the war drags on, only the antiSemites will win on Western countries, who - so Marx has taught us - are natural socialists.

My proposal, from the humanist perspective, is to phase an evacuation of everyone in Israel who is likely to suffer from a military strike. Those who seek peace with the Arab world can stay and hash out that peace, perhaps a dhimmat under the Damascenes.

Because being wrong shouldn't be a death sentence. But we also shouldn't be forced to pay for your nation-state.

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Uriah and Bathsheba, across three languages

Most people looking in on the old Greek for the Old Testament, called "Septuagint" in its first five books, will be using the Rahlfs edition. Yesterday I noted the Samuel-Saul cycle in 1-2 Reigns / Samuel, Thackeray-Barthélemy's α-ββ. Once David ben Jesse ascends the throne, which this poast will term 2 Reigns; we're in kaige territory.

Someone had gone in and fixed the Greek on its way to the good Professor-Doktor. Historically, scholars have blamed Lucian. Some ancient editors had tweaked (e.g.) the ββ elegy on Saul as well; but there we have better attestation of who did what and when. So Lucian has been deemed the earliest-attainable Greek for kaige.

Over 2019-21, some Finns came to the SBL conference and mooted that we may have witness to non-kaige readings. These show up as translations into Latin. One witness is Palimpsestus Vindobonensis, La115 for short. This covers 4:10–5:25, 10:13–11:19, 13:13–14:3, 17:12–18:9 (Timo Tekoniemi fn. 5).

Tekoniemi flagged 2R 5 vv. 4-5, 21, 24 all still ββ, then 10:19 and 11:17 which over in Greek have since gone kaige. For chapter 5 Tekoniemi found - respectively - parallels with 4QSama's chronology, taking of Philistine idols for - as MT, against ββ - destroying them, and a hint at Asherah-groves. La115's 5:4-5 and 24 readings must precede even the majority ββ but the 5:21 reading is more Lucian-ic. In 10:19, the Latin hints that David with Aram made a "covenant" (*יכרתו); everyone else says it was a "peace". In 11:17, the Latin allows for more blame upon David than the MT/Rahlfs will allow. Those will be early too.

In 2019 Tuukka Kauhanen had taken on 2 Reigns 11:11, where David's sin is more-explained. Tekoniemi aware of Kauhanen elsewhere did not use this one paper. Kauhanen for 11:11 argued for Rahlfs and Barthélemy. La115 mostly backs this.

The Lucianic text is, then, post-kaige.

Monday, November 9, 2026

Handsome Saul

When waiting for the shop to swap out some defective car-parts Friday, I got to skim that TC journal with my free oversweetened coffee-machine product. They're on the Scholarly Publishing Collective now. A lot of it concerned the transmissions of the Masoretic and the Greek; this morn we handle 2 Reigns. The most defective part of the Masoretic Text.

Our part of 2 Reigns concerns the death of Saul. In Greek this is in Thackeray's first eight-or-nine ββ chapters, which Barthélemy considered (relatively) unadulterated by later editors. The rest of the volume will be "kaige" sometimes ascribed to Lucian. Zachary Margulies here accepts a 2021 Oxford "handbook" consensus that the Codex Vaticanus ("B") preserves all 2 Reigns pretty well (protoHexaplaric?). That old Greek somewhat-famously translates the 4Q51 / Sama scraps, against the Masoretic Hebrew which... ain't great, for the Reigns quartet. Unfortunately that Qumran scrap does not preserve Margulies' subject, which is the lament for Saul. As to the Vetus Latina, we get no aid from the Palimpsestus Vindobonensis nor the Quedlinburg.

It turns out that the old Greek for ββ did suffer a bit of emendation outside of B's tradition. That emendation is the Lucianic tradition of Antioch ("L"). This affected the lament.

The Vaticanus (and Alexandrinus... and Sahidic) called the subject ὡραῖος, which means "beautiful". And, yeah: the footnotes point to Old Latin scraps with pulchri as an ephebic beauty. (Paging Al Sharpton.) In this context, which is Saul and not, say, Jonathan: that Greek doesn't work. The Lucianic made him εὐπρεπεῖς, which in kaige 23:1 is "handsome" or "dashing". Margulis concludes the Lucianic is improving a sus translation. The base Hebrew for Jonathan's good looks should be the same: נעים, to follow beloved Saul נאהב.

Of some interest here, perhaps, I see that the corrections toward the Hebrew do not encompass deletions against the Aleppo/Putingrad codices. The Hebrew proto-MT (as "II Samuhel") was already corrupted when Jerome got to it.

Sunday, November 8, 2026

From XR-100 to H10

I looked at a Nested Hall Thruster - from 19-22 August 2019. I figured it time for any updates on that tech since sometimes things just fall out of view, like that weedy aerogel fission scheme. In the Hall case, matters are looking better.

Specific-impulse is a function of reach and vice-versa. NASA would like the 3.1 ks which the Dawn ion-drive used to orbit Vesta and on to Ceres. Taxpayers lament, however, Dawn's extreme expense. Plenty of cool rocks remain floating out there; we can settle for something more like Psyche which as of this poast has been running smooth for 1.8 ks. Hall thrusters are cheaper than ion drives such as VASIMR. Hall Thrusters have been for stationkeepers and inter-orbit tugs. That ain't nothin'.

But Hall-effect plasma will degrade the engine. This requires some kind of shield; ablative (somehow) or magnetic. This allows operations in the kilohours, to span something between a day and a few months; when what propellant you'd brought would be used. Here's the focus of the last few years.

Here's JPL's H10.

This is a form of Hall Effect Rocket with Magnetic Shielding which NASA in 2022 was labelling HERMeS. For Hall Isp, the 2019 presentation had clustered 2 ks; HERMeS in 2022 was 2.78 ks from 12 kW. Now for the real ks, the operating-time...

JPL are saying that over the past few years, their lifespan has improved from the kilohours to 10-30 kh which I'm pretty sure refers to that HERMeS. This lifespan is a gift of the "MeS" side, citing this magnet paper from 2024 (running 8187 h so, slightly over a year). The excited plasma would be krypton or xenon for 50-60% efficiency. This is a lot better than the 20% it used to be; dunno if they'll move to argon.

This occasioned a battle of the kiloseconds, as operating-time feuded with... Isp. HERMeS ran into a voltage-limit: beyond 500 V, oscillations ruin the flow. Various mitigations are being researched; JPL has decided, for now, not to bother. Instead they increase power density, implicitly a function of mass so W/g here. That shifts the problem to thermodynamics - throwing out all those watts. JPL deal with that, with a segmented radiator that is coupled to high temperature components.

JPL say H10 has tested for peak performance at 800 V, 10 kW of 457 mN thrust, 3400 s specific impulse, and an efficiency of 76%. Its mass is 20 kg for an alpha of 2 kg/kW (lower is better).

I do believe we can supply 10 kW in space with a lightweight heat source, like with neutron-activated enthalpy. How to shield this engine; I don't know if superconductors be possible, or needed.

LIVE FIRE 11/14: Vast. But with krypton, for testing. 400 V would deliver 467 mN thrust, 2700 s specific impulse, and an efficiency of 62%; 600 V and 12 kW: 482 mN, 3100 s, 61%. 800 V should butt up to a half-newton but I don't know if they have the power for that.

The new Madduwattas

Hermann-Josef Stipp in his "Concept of Empty Land" (2010; ed. 2021) had argued in Jeremiah 37-44/44-51 for an affidavit of Ishmael's crimes as did not happen to involve Jeremiah. Stipp called this "The Ishmael File" even in 2010 so not as edgy as we'd deem it today.

That a file like this could exist, seems reasonable. Hittologists and Trojan War enjoyers have expended much ink on the Indictment of Madduwattas. Later, Ochus "Darius II" will be presiding over various complaints the Jews of the elephantine island were raising.

The original file would have been draughted over at Mizpah, by Ishmael's enemies. Chief among the latter would be Johanan, according to the file proper. Johanan then likely went to Nabuchadrezzar in person, or at least to his transeuphratic legate. His aim was to explain what happened to Gedaliah, to absolve himself and his coterie of blame, and to inform on the antagonist of the story Ishmael: still alive, and infesting the transjordanian hills.

When Johanan reports that Ishmael had killed everybody, he means everyone who matters to the great king. When he notes women among the men, he is playing to the king's sense of pathos, inasmuch as he owned one; alternatively, the king injected this for reasons I'll get to.

Pace Stipp (2010 ed.) p. 124 I deem easier how come this ephemeral affidavit was preserved. The great king would have kept his own copy, likely wedged into Akkadian and baked into clay. More copies would have been gone to the Judaean quarter in Babylon: this would tell the exiles that, yes, a rebellion had broken out back home, but don't get your hopes up. Nabuchadrezzar would not fail to note that Ishmael had butchered women too, that villain. And of course the king would have sent some troops either to back up Johanan or else to see if he was lying.

At some point in the narrative we got, comes Johanan's personal motive, to protect the remnant of Judah from obliteration. This has Johanan warn Gedaliah of Ishmael's plans in advance, in the hope Gedaliah will get at Ishmael first (which he didn't). I don't know how much of that went to the king; more likely it went into the local annal, as Johanan presented his case before his own people, several of whom might grouse that Ishmael had done nothing wrong and/or that Johanan was an opportunistic vulture. Stipp would roll that whole account into the "JDP", arguing that such existed to showcase the emptying of Judah and the fulfilment of the Deuteronomic curse; all beyond my scope. We do agree that Jeremiah MT 44 be a pseudepigraph, likely Baruch's work.

As for Jeremiah (perhaps more-so, Baruch): if they hadn't been in Mizpah, they were no victims of the massacre of collaborators. Although Jeremiah was uninvolved (he was probably in Egypt already) he assuredly agreed with Johanan's action. Baruch, perhaps, had inserted the prophet (his hero) into the events so as to make of him an eyewitness.

The remnant of Judah

Miika Tucker in TC raises a study of that infamous LXX/MT dispute over Jeremiah, here what is 40-44 in MT. Mainly this is in dialogue with Hermann-Josef Stipp "Empty Land" (2021), who'd covered MT 37-43 as a Narrative of Judah’s Downfall in Palestine (JDP).

Tucker figures that before we allow higher critics like Stipp to gaily trample the clover, we should be restoring the earliest attainable Hebrew. Everyone but the most cretinous fundamentalist knows that the ancient Jews messed up this particular text. (They did it to 2 Reigns too.) But before we play the drunken Klingon and tout the "original Greek", the Graecophones had their own agendae with the text. This assigns to Tucker some work to do.

The top tier - the very Masoretic - relays a few variants against the Targum, a few more against the Vulgate, and the most against Peshitta. MT appears a "Byzantine" text in 41:10 and 42:2, incorporating a doublet which came from variant readings in the proto-MT(s); probably Hebrew but possibly some ancient Aramaic targum or Hebrew pesher.

MT 42:12 is more deliberate. The proto-MT had Jeremiah (perhaps through Baruch) quote the Lord: And I will grant you mercy, and I will have mercy on you and return you to your land. MT instead has the Lord promise this through Nabuchadrezzar. Tucker thinks the Hebrew behind Peshitta was using infinitive constructions, which are good CBH, but archaic for Qumran-era Hebrew (we see similar loss of infinitive in modern Greek against the remoter dialects, like Pontic). That would make that Hebrew, likewise CBH, to be taken seriously. The MT nod to Nabuchadrezzar would reflect a pro-'Iraq tendency, (I think) for Roman times maybe Trajan's.

Before proto-MT, MT 37-44 would be 44–51. This, Tucker's third chapter, is the strongest in my view. It follows a section to distinguish the synopsis "remnant" from the proto-MT's understanding thereof.

For Jeremiah himself, Nabuchadrezzar wasn't all bad, either; recall that it all went wrong when the Judaeans resisted him in the first place. In the 40/47 synopsis, Gedaliah is a benevolent governor for the imperium, appointing men and women. MT has men and "poor and children(!)"; LXX, men and "their wives". Tucker notes the MT parallels children in MT 43:6 as exiles; "poor" agree with plusses in MT 39:10 and 52:16 also not in Greek. In MT 40 this would simply be a harmony which the (proto-)MT made up. The idea was to paint Gedaliah as a gatherer of all the exiles, beyond being a fair governor for the (home) "remnant". Proto-MT has a theology of remnant-in-exile, which we'll be seeing shared in Leontopolis and Qumran. The remnant for the Jeremiah synopsis is to follow the prophet.

Because Gedaliah's Eden could not last. One Ishmael - who might have been a Davidide - murdered the man, synopsis 41/48, with a general massacre in Mizpah. In Greek, Ishmael butchered "everybody", which he could do in Greek where the relevant population are direct male and female agents of Nabuchadrezzar. Proto-MT here restricts the killing to "soldiers". Tucker argues that this had to happen because proto-MT had earlier stuffed Mizpah with total innocents. Even in Greek, Ishmael orders survivors (including Jeremiah and Baruch, not deemed collaborators) out of Mizpah, toward the Jordan and old Ammon. Then one Johanan chases Ishmael's caravan. In Greek, they "turn to" Johanan; in proto-MT, they rejoice. For Tucker, the proto-MT is "indicting" the people for rebelling against Ishmael. Proto-MT is generally pro-David; MT proper (to repeat) will be making a return to commending the Babylonians.

In the 43/50 synopsis Ishmael then leaves his refugees, or hostages, on the west-bank as he slips across the river into Ammon.

Chapter 44/51, which Stipp has dismissed as a Deuteronomic homily, teleports the prophet into Egypt. This centres a Deuteronomic speech from Jeremiah. The prophet here addresses all the Judaeans (now) in Misraym, which indeed includes Manuf / Memphis. The speech indicts the Judaean kingdom for its disobedience, and promises more chastisement in their place of supposed refuge. MT adds the present generation, and extends the smiting to Jews worldwide. Tucker surmises that the proto-MT does not want the remnant to be sojourning in - anywhere.

Tucker thus disagrees with Stipp on the finer meaning of "remnant" for that one's projected JDP. JDP might just be a chapter-section of Baruch's wider compilation of Jeremiah lore. Stipp's "Ishmael file" must await its own poast.

Saturday, November 7, 2026

A plank in our eyes

As part of the Trump I era project The Extreme Right and the Revision of History; S.J. Pearce reviews Fernández-Morera.

This blog first reviewed The Myth back in 2019, when (I assume) Pearce was still revising his takedown. Mine own review dinged it for not spending time on its "Song Duchy" phase, before those Nāfiʿ codices trickled over there ~200/800. We can however evaluate if Pearce' review be any better than its object (or, target) - on the review's own standards.

Pearse' review claims that The Myth strawmans The Ornament of the World in particular, on its way to pillorying wider academia. Indeed: Fernández-Morera had got his book published through ISI, a sort of refuge for frustrated para-academics in an appeal to a wider (conservative) market. Pearse further pins Fernández-Morera to the Spanish Right, in particular Franco in 1939, which he associates more narrowly to the Phalangists.

The overall book's call-for-abstracts suggests that the editors had no desire to impose basic sobriety upon the submissions. If you're not on the team, you're Extreme Right. And you deserve to be punched.

Whatever The Ornament printed about how Catholic (or Jewish) life went under the Maliki dhimma: the title chosen was - as we say now - clickbait, for people who wanted to believe in a multicultural Chrislam like we got in Twohy's Pitch Black movies. Looking around this 'ere blog, direct apologetic for Corboda's amirate is rife in quasi-historical text like the pious asides in Covey. I suppose Moller's 105-IQ takes might count as less scholarly... except that her book got rave reviews by mainstream newspapers who usually pull their reviewers from the universities; it also got blurbed by Nixey.

Fernández-Morera intuited that The Ornament had a Tendenz, which he could extrapolate from its reception-history.

If we don't allow Fernández-Morera to attack a vibe, a midwit fad, surrounding a text; then I wonder why Pearce or his editors imagine that we should allow Pearse to attack a "far right" or "extreme(!) right" surrounding Fernández-Morera's text.

I also have to ask why an anti-Islamist book should be considered "far" ... anything. I can assuredly rank Franco with the far right, if not as far as - say - Carlism (or Tolkien). To that: even if we're eschewing the Almoravid "fundamentalism"; we're invited to compare Franco with a hereditary amirate backed by Malikite fiqh and a standard Qurân. If the Umayyad state was anything, it was a political project to be judged accordingly. I beg of Pearse to find any moderation in that.

Fernández-Morera wasn't writing about Spain in its 1930s. As an aside, I don't think Franco would much approve an antiMoroccan text, himself; given how the Moroccans helped him win.

Much of Pearse' review is just namecalling. Here we must handle his treatment of the Phalanx. If Pearse could read Spanish, or even use Google Translate in its 2019 edition, he should know that the Phalanx appealed to a racial Spain bypassing Islam and Christianity both. "Phalanx" evokes no history in Spain; it evokes classical Greece. Frankly that crew were kinda gay, sort of a Spanish Sturmabteilung. Franco like... that other guy... could use such a Front, but he never much controlled them and he'd come to get rid of them. If you would like to know more (so-to-speak): also from 2020 we have AH Lloyd.

A proper review of Fernández-Morera's project would be welcome. Pearse cannot provide it.

Friday, November 6, 2026

Knovíz

Northeast Europeans got two papers recently: on the Germans and on the Celts. I am mainly discussing the Celts.

By the time the Greeks noticed the great Rhône hinterland from their Massilia, it was a "Galatía". The paper's "3200-2800 BP" is the post-Bronze Dark Age; already the legendary past for the Massilia colonists, who as colonists cared more about Greek legend than about Gaulish. Although some Gauls did claim some Heracles-slept-here type of cross-cultural tropes.

That paper is noting the migrations which brought a common Gaulish to the Greek Riviera. A few decades ago, scholars tended to blur these, not having excellent dates and lacking genetics. Bell Beakers (formerly, battle axes) northwest; Corded Ware in the north, and something-or-other at Knovíz. About the only agreement was that the Germans won't show up until about the time Caesar shows up.

We are now finding that Knovíz, which looks a lot like La Tène (and, in north Italy, Urnfield), drove one final migration in that Iron Age. It would have been them - "Hallstatt C" - who took Britain 700s BC. They seem also to have crossed the Pyrenees into northeast Hispania/Iberia.

Ireland's conservative Goidelic remains unconstrained here, the paper simply noting that earlier papers are clustering around the same time as the Hallstatt C invasion of Britain. Irish myth remembers multiple arrivals, and maybe even the Halberd / Beaker divide; but we cannot pin dates to anything before the great Iona chronicles.

I expect earlier migrations had already fed Lusitanian into our Portugal, and Italic into you-know-where. At least the former had been primed toward Indo-European by the Bell Beakers; so shifting to (Lusato-)Italo-Celtic would have been like a shift between Tocharian dialects for them, or from Median to Imperial Persian. The great Gaulish push, likewise, would not have been drastic. Latin was effectively a back migration, so wasn't drastic either. Etruscan into Italy of course would have been drastic, even under Gaulish leadership; and on defence the Euskara are still refusing Romance.

As for later, a Celtic helm ended up in Łysa Góra. That's at Bagienice, later part of Old Prussia around where the Tolkien family came from. Tacitus is there translated/quoted: On the right coast of the Suebian Sea [the Baltic Sea] dwell the Aestian nations, whose customs and attire are the same as those of the Suebians, but their language more resembles that of Britain. As such the "Aesti" folk might share a name with the modern Estonia but a Finnic language is ruled out. Whether this be a holdover from "Hallstatt C" or from some British trade-colony: hard to say. If the latter, it doesn't look like a recent colony.

Thursday, November 5, 2026

Korea's insane membrane

Korea's answer to DARPA or Skunk, KAIST in Roman acronym, can now refine oil without heat; with the help of Georgia Tech. This allows to skip modular reactors.

They use a polyacrylonitrile membrane, a type used elsewhere but not for crude. They claim that the heavier hydrocarbons attach themselves to the membrane but not so finely as to turn it into a barrier. The lighter oils will still flow. 23 times the permeability of anything else.

They'll flow for a full 28 days before needing to swap the membrane, which as noted is presently a commodity.

Downstream of this, the tech might turn various wastes into something useful. Pyrolysis oil from recycling plastics, solvents from battery-cell manufacture.

Wednesday, November 4, 2026

Hebrews, Pauline sermon upon 1 Peter

Some excellent work from Elizabeth Myers, as expounded by Carrier: the sermon to the "Hebrews" might have derived from 1 Peter 2:5.

"Hebrews" would then have accepted 1 Peter as Scripture, of a sort; reacting to that text. The author of "Hebrews" himself was an ultraPauline, arguing to his audience to abandon all Jewish practices. Paul in his own time had allowed that Jews existed alongside Gentiles so was unwilling to push the former from being Jews at home.

Carrier isn't (yet) taking a side on the Hebrews / 1 Clement parallels, and in this case it's unimportant. The point is that he endorses Myers on 1 Peter being earlier than both.

1 Peter, Myers and Carrier further contend, is not much intersecting with Paul at all (as 1 Clement and Hebrews - and Mark - intersect). So 1 Peter might really be Peter's. Carrier goes on (like, mooting that 1 Peter was written in the Parthic Eraq) but - whatevs. I need to track back, to the Peter / Paul intersection. Where's Marcar 2016? That pointed to 1 Peter's knowledge of Paul's letter to the Romans.

Tuesday, November 3, 2026

Abû Isḥâq's Kufian tafsîr

Abû Isḥâq of al-Kûfa - brace for diacritics, tonight - was a legal specialist under the caliph Hishâm and for a few years of the chaos he left behind, d. AD 745. Most Muslims approve of him across confessional boundaries, which boundaries Najm Haider has proven already existed, especially after the Zayd bin ʿAlî mess. Andreas Görke is looking into one of Abû Isḥâq's sources, where he needed Qurânic warrant. This source is one al-Barâʾ bin ʿÂzib, d. 72/691.

That date is a banner year in Islam: the date pinned to the Dome of the Rock, and remembered as Unity Year. It falls also over a half century before the death of his best student.

Before I get into that, I must preface that Görke is one of the best scholars of early Islamic tradition we have. It's been awhile since I last looked at his take on Abû Mijlaz, and the two traditions in Tidings of Flame didn't intersect with that project's traditions (and are rejected anyhow); but I had no problem with Görke's summary, and I don't find where others had, either. Abû Mijlaz however died in the 100s AH. His floruit would have covered the final imprimatur upon the Umayyad codex under caliph Walîd and his pitbull Ḥajjâj in the ʿIrâq, flowing into the Sulaymân and ʿUmar II caliphates. Barâʾ is earlier.

Görke convinces me that Barâʾ existed - and that he taught a school. The paper offers ʿAdī b. Ṯābit (d. c. 116/734), Saʿd b. ʿUbayda (d. 101/719), Khaythama (b. ʿAbd al-Raḥmān, d. 82/701), Zādhān Abū ʿAmr (d. c. 83/702) and Abū Mālik al-Ghifārī (d. between 100/718 and 110/728), all of whom are Kufan. Zâdhân and Khaythama would have outlived their teacher by only a decade.

Abû Isḥâq outlived every name in that school. Sure: he is also reported, or reputed, born 33/654, in which case Abû Isḥâq could have sat in on the Barâʾ classes in his thirties. That this one student also transmitted the most lore, I find sus.

I should like some research on when exactly Abû Isḥâq was transmitting to others. I have a feeling his transmissional peak will be under Hishâm, and not before. Most of these other students were transmitting before or during caliph ʿUmar, contemporary with Abû Mijlaz. Their students eschewed Abû Isḥâq at the time. If Abû Isḥâq was in late middle age and at the peak of his brainpower: why skip him?

Also to be added is that "Barâʾ" is recorded as transmitting relatively conservative vocalisations of the rasm. Relative to ... Abû Mijlaz, with the suras 92 and 99 I'd checked (and to repeat, I reject Abû Mijlaz on each). The "Barâʾ" readings follow what I expect of the generation of Abû Isḥâq, as Arthur Jeffery reported from al-Aʿmash (d. 148/764). By diachrony, Abû Mijlaz makes sense. Al-Barâʾ does not.

I propose that these early Barâʾ transmitters skipped Abû Isḥâq because Abû Isḥâq was, then, a student himself. Abû Isḥâq was not born in the 30s/650s. Rather, during the 100s/720s, our man compiled a Kûfic tafsîr from multiple sources, for his own use, which he ascribed to al-Barâʾ. Nobody else was allowed to copy this notebook.

Monday, November 2, 2026

Beyond Chandrasekhar

Five years ago I noted large dwarf ZTF J1901+1458, pondering if it be metastable. One way out might be spin. But stars also have magnetic fields; neutron stars on the other side certainly do, and black holes at least have charge. So here is a study showing what magnets do to WDs.

The Chandrasekhar Limit thereby is an ideal: for the nonmagnetic star, or maybe a 'dwarf whose collapse (from the red giant) scrambled its dynamo. Thing is, I don't think that ever happens. So the Limit of an existent dwarf needs to take into account its gausses and/or teslas.

This suggests a sub-type-2 supernova. Take the starved overlarge dwarf. It never gobbles sufficient matter at once to light that ("standard") Type I candle. It might, however, nibble lightly. As it ages and the dynamo drops too low, and the mass increases: implosion.

Sunday, November 1, 2026

The Syrian canon of Ignatius

Dan Batovici got "Four New Syriac Witnesses to the Middle Recension of the Ignatian Corpus" published in 2020, which you may read in Google Books since he's posted only the first page on Academia.edu. The title is a misnomer. In detail-of-fact, Batovici argues their witness for a canon florilegium: taken from six of the saint's letters. Ephesians, Magnesians, Trallians, Philadelphians, Smyrnaeans, and to Polycarp. This is relayed in west-Syrian canons (we may assume, Miaphysite).

The Greeks preserved a recension of all six letters in full plus one to the Romans. Those intersect with a collection of three: Polycarp, Ephesians - and Romans. Romans, further, is relayed in full in the Acts of this holy martyr. In Coptic (Sahidic, I think) survive fragments translated from all but Magnesians, adding Romans and one to Hero; such a collection exists also in Syriac.

The Syrian canon preserves some deviations, especially in the paratext. Some are startling: what is known from the Greeks as Trallians is, here, to "Titilians".

One variant perhaps shouldn't startle: the letter to the Smyrnians is generally "Church of Asia". We may be seeing an echo of that ancient Smyrna / Ephesus rivalry. We know that the Ephesians forced their name upon Paul's letter thereto, which in the MSS does not mention Ephesus and whose paratext for Marcion went to Laodicea. As to the Ignatian collection(s): pro-Ephesians perhaps insisted that their fellow Greeks restrict that other letter to Smyrna, alone. If so, I for one side with the Ephesians. This letter names Smyrna and I don't think it's a manuscript intrusion. It is written from Troas, and the Ephesians are called brothers to the letter's recipients.